CFF60 review - NAME YOUR POISON by Paddy Hayes

The story of Michael Molloy, the Irish man who wouldn't die. NAME YOUR POISON is a documentary by PADDY HAYES, and screened at the 60th CORK FILM FESTIVAL.

Every year there is a number of bi-lingual documentaries, in the English language and Irish language, produced in Ireland and primarily aimed at a television audience. Most of them remain quite similar, but are nevertheless a treat to watch on the big screen. Such is the case with the extremely likeable and entertaining NAME YOUR POISON by PADDY HAYES, that tells the fascinating story of a man who would not die. 

Set in the Bronx in the Great Depression, this is a tale that has effectively made it into american folklore of the first half of he twentieth century. It tells the true story of a man named Michael Molloy, an Irish immigrant, who was a hopeless alcoholic. His desperate state was so much that he was effectively worth more dead than alive to a bunch of crooks who ran a bar and, after taking out a policy on his life, attempted to murder him in countless of ways, with countless of their attempts failing. 

HAYES understands the dark comedy appeal of the story, and uses a number of ways to make NAME YOUR POISON all the more entertaining as a result. One of these is the use of recreation. Despite the dodgy American accents by an obviousl bunch of Irish fellows, these are a lot of fun and reveal the story's potential as a piece of fictional cinema based on a true story. On top of that, it is shot in a speakeasy lighting sort of way, and with a style that recalls the gangster flicks and classics set in the Great Depression. This style is also employed in the more factual moments of the film - for instant in the introductions of the experts.

Nevertheless, NAME YOUR POISON also has a deeper side that explores in quite a rewarding way its more human subjects of vulnerability and immigration. That is what ultimately makes the documentary more rewarding than simply being a "bit of fun". It also takes a peek at the desperate conditions that will drive men to doing immoral and terrible things they might otherwise have never done had they not been put under great strains. In this case, one would be inclined to think that the reason for this repetition of terrible acts committed on Molloy would have beem due to the state of extreme poverty that hit the United States during the period known as the Great Depression.

Furthermore, it also draws a parallel between the old and new in a further enrichment of its story. Irish audience will be happy to see Anthony Molloy featured as the film's main narrator and voice. A former Gaelic footballing hero - Gaelic being one of the main national sports in Ireland - he went down in the history of the sport as being the first captain to lift the All-Ireland title for Donegal, in 1992. He claims at the start that he always thought himself as the toughest Molloy who ever lived, until he heard about Michael Molloy, also known as the Rasputin of the Bronx due to his legendary status. Despite the two not being related by blood, there is something that ties them together - the shadow of alcoholism, with which Anthony had to deal with himself, and which he candidly talks about.